Resources / Writing / Keep the idea. Fix the drawing.

Keep the idea. Fix the drawing.

DabbleU’s logo had the right concept and the wrong execution. Here’s the before and after.

DabbleU is the learning side of Dabble, and it has its own logo. We redrew it.

Not every logo project needs a new idea. Sometimes the concept is already great and the execution is what’s holding it back, and the job is to reduce and simplify until the idea can actually show up.

The idea was right

A graduation cap, because it’s a school. The parent brand’s feather, because it’s Dabble. A big U, because that’s the name. Three good ideas, all pointed in the right direction.

The execution wasn’t

The U was red, and it didn’t need to be.

The cap perched on the D read juvenile, closer to clip art than to a school.

And the Dabble feather was tilted and hung upside down off the cap as a tassel (the feather did not sign up for this). The name already says Dabble. The feather was saying it a second time, sideways.

Same ideas, better execution

The U went black, so the name reads as one word. The cap got redrawn flat and simple, and moved from the D over to the U, so the letter the sub-brand is named for is the one wearing it. The feather’s colors stayed on in the cap and the tassel, small enough to be a nod instead of a second logo.

Nothing got thrown out. Every concept from the original is still in there, just doing its job with less. A new concept would have thrown away the part that was already working.

Before you scrap your logo, write down what it’s trying to say. If the list is right, keep the ideas and redraw them.

— Zach