Stop singing about Satan
Glowing orbs and purple gradients are the AI version of a pentagram album cover
Metallica figured out in 1985 what most AI brands still haven’t.
In 1985, at Day on the Green, MTV asked James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich what made Metallica different from the other heavy bands of the moment, the Slayers and the Megadeths.
Hetfield laughed and said, “Maybe you’re not into Satan.”
Lars gave the serious answer: bands “catch on to a lot of the cliches,” and Metallica try “to shy away from as many of them as we can.”
Through the 80s and 90s, Satan was the default subject in metal, and Slayer is the obvious example. Musically I’ve got no beef with them, they’ve got some genuinely great stuff and my dad once got mistaken for Kerry King (Slayer's guitarist) while at one of their shows... it was awesome. But lyrically, an album called Hell Awaits is an easy grab. It’s the most accessible dark thing on the shelf, and half the genre was reaching for it. It took zero soul.
Satan, blah, blah, blah, we're so dark, blah, blah, blaaaahhhhhh.
Metallica reached somewhere else.
“One” comes from Johnny Got His Gun, the story of a soldier who comes home from war without his arms, legs, eyes, ears, or mouth, and begs to be put on display so people can see what war actually does.
“For Whom the Bell Tolls” is Hemingway, title and all.
“Creeping Death” walks you through the ten plagues of Egypt, straight out of Exodus.
“The Call of Ktulu” is pure mythology, and they didn’t even need lyrics for that one. The title did the work.
War novels, scripture, Hemingway, myth. Every one of those is darker and stranger than a pentagram, and none of them sounded like anybody else.
AI companies are singing about Satan.
Okay, not the literal Satan... but they are falling into the same trap as the metal bands who actually did.
Glowing orbs. Purple gradients. The little sparkle icon. Magic wands, glowing neural spaghetti, a robot hand reaching out to touch a human one. It’s all so cliché within the category that it’s become the brand equivalent of a .ai domain: a tell. It tells me the team lacked imagination and grabbed the most accessible branding idea within reach.
We’ve seen this movie before. Plenty of blockchain technology was genuinely cool. But the second a company threw the word “blockchain” on its homepage, the warning lights went on, and a lot of good tech never recovered from its own marketing.
AI isn’t there yet. People are still receptive. But it isn’t the core feature of your product, either. Calling yourself an AI-native company in 2026 is like calling yourself an internet company. DUH.
It’s the water we all swim in. David C. Baker and Blair Enns said it on 2Bobs better than I can: having AI, or using it, is nothing special. It just is, no different than breathing or saying you use a computer.
Nobody bought a Metallica record because it was loud. Everything in metal was loud. What Metallica had was interest in something else with lyrics and subject matter to prove it.
So put the AI down for a second and look at the market you’re actually selling into. Who are these people, what problem keeps them up at night, and what does their world look, sound, and feel like? That’s your Hemingway or your Exodus. There’s more branding ammo to pull from there than a purple gradient will ever give you.
More important, what makes you feel the way you want other people to feel about you? What well can you bring up water from that isn't surrounded by 100 other brands trying to get a taste?
Don’t sing about Satan. (You shouldn’t be singing about Satan in the first place, but that’s a Saturday issue.)
Go find richer material.
— Zach
