Resources / Writing / Why bring kids into a world like this?

Why bring kids into a world like this?

Over barbecue, a guy told me he could never have kids. I asked him one question he couldn’t answer. ~4 min.

This is the deep end, and it's the one day of my newsletter regimen that is purely philosophical and not design related. Enjoy!

I was at a conference this week and got to talking with a guy named Paco. While devouring some barbecue together, the conversation went somewhere I didn’t expect, and he told me he didn’t think he could bring kids into this world.

Not “not yet.” Not “we’re waiting until things settle down.” He just didn’t think he could do it, and he thought it would be a bad thing if he did.

His reasons were far from flippant. He didn’t want a kid of his to endure the negativity, the poverty, or the emotional suffering that comes from personal grievances or from bearing witness. On top of that, he didn’t think the world was going to be any better by the time they grew up. If anything, he figured it’d be worse.

It sounds like compassion, right?

That’s what makes it hard to push back on. On its face, his desire to not have kids isn’t selfish. It’s somebody looking at the world, then looking at a kid who doesn’t exist yet, and deciding to spare them the anguish.

I get it. Open any news app on your phone and you’ll have a gaggle of reasons to agree with him before you finish your morning coffee (which I don't drink, but most of you do, I'm sure).

But the longer I sat with it, the less it held together. Because the argument isn’t really about kids. It’s about whether you think things can get better or whether we’re royally screwed.

So I asked him: then why be here at all?

If the world is so broken that it would be cruel to put a new person in it, why are you still here?

You’re still getting up in the morning. You’re still going to work, still trying to get better at something, still flying across the country to sit next to a bald guy at a software conference and learn. Why?

He couldn't answer.

The way I see it, you’ve got two paths.

The first is nihilism. Nothing gets better, nothing you do matters, the whole thing is pointless. You’re allowed to believe that, but if you’re going to maintain your sanity, then you have to live like there is no point.

Stop building anything. Stop caring how your work turns out or how you treat people. Send it all to hell in a handbasket, because, at the end of the day, what’s the difference?

Paco might have those ideas, but his actions say otherwise.

The second path is believing things can get better, and living out the idea that people, actual regular people, can leave the world. And if you believe that, then having kids isn’t adding to the problem.

It’s the single most effective solution.

There’s no way those two worldviews can hold up at the same time, because the actions downstream from them are opposites.

Somebody’s going to raise the next generation

Here’s the part I keep coming back to: Paco is exactly the kind of person who should have kids.

He’s thoughtful. He cares about suffering enough to lose sleep over a kid who hasn’t even been born. That’s the person you’d want diving into parenthood. He gives a shit.

If the people who worry about making the world better all opt out, the world doesn’t get better. That gene goes extinct.

Every person who has ever cured something, built something, or made somebody else’s bad day a little lighter was somebody’s kid. Their parents looked at a world fraught with war and disease and poverty and brought new life into it anyway.

And no, you can’t spare a kid from suffering. My daughter is going to get her heart broken someday. She’s going to have days where the world feels exactly as heavy as Paco thinks it is. But I believe that she, and the young people around her, will be capable of confronting it and coming out on top.

Having kids is not ignoring how hard the world is and saying "good luck." Having kids is the bullet you place between suffering's eyes.

— Zach