Your palette is already out there
Why every software company is the same blue, and the easiest place to find a palette that isn’t.
Day two of the brand parts: color.
Color is one of the places you can differentiate yourself the most, and differentiation is the core reason to pick one in the first place.
I’ve seen countless software companies use the exact same blue, or the exact same gradient, as every one of their competitors. We ran into this with Prisma. When we lined their competition up side by side, it was the same greeny teal across the board. If your color matches your closest competitors’, every ad you run reminds people a little bit of them.
So you pick a color that’s different, and then you use it over and over and over again, until people can’t see it without thinking of you. Ask anyone what color Tiffany or Starbucks is, and they’ll answer before they’ve thought about it.
- Tiffany put its blue on the cover of its Blue Book catalog in 1845. Pantone later made it a custom color, 1837 Blue, named for the year Tiffany was founded, and the color is a registered trademark.
- UPS leaned so hard into brown that it ran an entire campaign asking “What can Brown do for you?”
- Starbucks has put the same green on every cup, apron, and storefront for decades.
- Coca-Cola has been using the same red consistently for decades as a unifying element between ads, packaging, and any other marketing asset.
- Cadbury spent years in court trying to trademark its purple, and lost. Even without a judge's approval, their consistent usage of the purple in a sea of reds, oranges, and browns on the candy bar shelf awards it to them anyway. People do the trademarking in their heads.
So where do you find a color palette?
You can stare at a color wheel, or you can do it the easy way: pick a palette that already exists somewhere out in the world. An album cover, a movie still, a storefront, a jacket. Something out there has already put colors next to each other in a way that makes you feel something. Photograph it, have an AI tool pull the swatches, and you’ve got a palette with the pairings already built in.
Our palette at Conversion Factory came off the cover of Kanye’s Jesus Is King. Nobody in our market was pulling from there, which is the point.
That’s why keeping a record of your muses matters so much. Every time something makes you feel the way you want people to feel about your brand, save it. When it’s time to pick a color, you’re not starting from a blank swatch, you’re flipping through a folder of things that already work.
Making color a toolset
A color on its own doesn’t make the feeling, the pairing does (the same red feels like a fast food menu next to yellow and like Target next to white). So you want a primary color you use over and over, secondary and tertiary colors that support it, and designated pairings: which colors go on which, which can carry body text, and which never touch.
Check every pairing for contrast (WCAG asks for 4.5:1 on body text) so whatever your team reaches for is legible. Also very easy to do with AI.
Less is more
Most designers will hand you a swatch library that contains 11 different tints and shades of each color. I think it's gratuitous. This is an opinion that I formed about a year ago, even the DevStats example of color swatches above has seven per color and it's too much. Here's why:
- Overkill. No one ever uses each swatch. Ever. Not once, guaranteed. Even in gradients, the colors fill in the gaps themselves. Five swatches per color is plenty.
- Analysis paralysis. When faced with 55 swatches between 5 base colors, you bury your team in choices they shouldn't have to make.
- Contrast. You want sufficient contrast and noticeable difference between swatches. A jump from 100 to 200 blue is too subtle. 100 to 300? Meaningfully different.
Here is what 5 swatches per color looks like: a base, two tints, and two shades, each one skipping a step on the scale. On a 100 to 900 scale, that’s your base at 500, tints at 300 and 100, and shades at 700 and 900. The gaps keep every swatch visibly different from its neighbors, so nobody on your team is squinting at 400 versus 500 (and nobody sneaks in a 450).
Remember, at its core, color is a representation of the emotions you want your users to feel. If you find yourself lost at the beginning, stop looking for color and start finding feelings. The next time an album cover, a storefront, or a movie still stops you in your tracks, save it. Your palette is probably already out there.
— Zach
