Feelings don’t have a stick shift
You can’t make someone feel brave. The Marines do it anyway, and your brand can too.
Rory Sutherland says the mind works like an automatic transmission, not a stick shift. Design is how you ease off the gas.
I’ve been listening to Rory Sutherland’s Alchemy on audio, and there’s enough branding wisdom hiding in it to fill a month of these newsletters. The idea I can’t shake is what he calls oblique influence.
He explains it with cars. Most of us drive an automatic, and you’d think that means you have no say in when it shifts gears. You do.
You can hear it in the engine, feel it in the pedal and in the way the car pulls, and if you ease off the gas at the right moment on the freeway, the car shifts when you want it to. You can’t force the shift, you coax it.
A manual is the opposite. You grab the stick, touch the clutch, and put the car into gear. And here’s the funny part: manual drivers are actually worse at coaxing an automatic, because they’re so used to forcing the shift that they never learned to feel for it with the same level of subtlety.
Emotions and branding work like the automatic. Most people trying to change how someone feels are reaching for a stick that isn’t there.
You can’t order someone to be brave
Rory’s example is bravery. Say you need someone to become braver to equip them with the spirit needed to fly across the world and fight an enemy. There’s no switch for that. You can’t tell a person “be brave... now!” and watch it happen, because the only one who can flip that switch is them, from the inside and, furthermore, subconsciously.
The military has figured this out better than anyone, and they come at it from both directions.
Some of it is close to manual. Harsh training, regimentation, routine, a drill instructor in your face until confidence stops being a feeling and turns into homeostasis. That’s force, and it works, up to a point.
But a surprising amount of it is oblique. Think about the pressed uniform. Marching in step. Trumpets and drums. The color guard. The pins on the chest. The war cries of special operations units and branches: Hooyah, Oorah, Hooah, and more. None of those makes anyone brave (not one). But stack them all together and you’ve built a place where a young recruit is most likely going to flip the bravery switch on their own.
Then there are the lines they say about themselves. The few, the proud, the Marines. Be all you can be. Aim high. Semper Fi. The SEALs’ “the only easy day was yesterday.” And my favorite, the unofficial Marine one, a riff on an old FedEx tagline (yes, a brand line): when it absolutely, positively has to be destroyed overnight, send the Marines.
It goes back further than recruiting posters, too. The Gadsden flag is a coiled rattlesnake and three words: don’t tread on me. Patrick Henry didn’t lay out a policy argument, he said give me liberty or give me death.
Not one of them says “be brave.” Every one of them tells you who you get to be if you are and encourages you to join in.
That’s fighting spirit, and a lot of it is purposeful pageantry.
All design is oblique influence
So what does this have to do with branding? Everything, because design is the oblique part.
Color palette, typography, language, illustration style, presentation, how well it all hangs together, and how sure of itself it looks. None of those tells anyone how to feel. They just make it easier to get there.
Richter Guardian protects high-net-worth families and executives from digital threats. The feeling we were after was luxurious, nostalgic, and refined, without being too on the nose about any of it.
The old site was a stick shift. A yacht full of rich people in the hero, in case you missed who it was for, and an all-caps headline announcing “your state-of-the-art solution to protect your digital life.” It told you what to feel, and you didn’t feel it.
The new one never says wealthy, and it never says safe. It’s warm paper instead of black, a deep green straight off old money, an italic serif carrying the emotional weight (“from digital threats”), and the fine geometric rings you’d find engraved on currency tucked into the background. The guy in the hero isn’t on a yacht, he’s checking his phone in a well-lit office. Even the button got quieter: “Request a private consultation.” And the fine print underneath, “all consultations and communications are handled confidentially,” does more for secure than any headline could.
Nothing on that page tells you you’re rich or protected. Every piece of it just eases off the gas.
You’re not forcing the feeling. You’re making it easy for them to get there on their own.
Which is why you start with the feeling
This is why every branding project I run starts with the same question: how do you want people to feel?
Without an answer, there’s nothing to coax anyone toward. Every color, every typeface, every illustration becomes its own little opinion, they all pull in different directions, and the whole thing goes by the wayside. With an answer, every one of those inputs eases off the gas at the same moment, and the shift actually happens.
The military knows exactly which feeling it’s after. Most brands never decide.
You can’t force a feeling, but you can influence it... and that, my friend, is design.
— Zach
